| Platinum | Bookery Cafe |
| Gold | Bearded Baking Co |
| Silver | Queen City Cupcakes |
| Bronze | The Pie Guy |
| Top Pick | Buckley's Bakery & Cafe |
| Top Pick | Cinnabon |
| Top Pick | Dishon Bakery |
| Top Pick | Dulces Bakery, LLC |
| Top Pick | The Bakeshop On Kelley Street |
| Top Pick | The Spot Eatery |