| Platinum | Jimmy's House Of Pizza |
| Gold | Pizza By Rocco |
| Silver | Chelby's Pizza & Subs |
| Bronze | Clementos |
| Top Pick | Alley Cat Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Elm House of Pizza |
| Top Pick | Grand Slam Pizza |
| Top Pick | Luigi's Pizza Bar & Grille |
| Top Pick | South Side Tavern |
| Top Pick | Vintage Pizza |